• Services
    • Transformation Consultants
    • Safety Consultants
    • Leadership and Organizational Performance
    • Major Capital Projects
    • High Integrity Turnarounds™
    • The School of Coaching
  • Impact
    • What Clients Say
    • Client Results
  • Insights
    • Articles, Blogs & Poetry
    • Press Releases
    • Events
    • Transformation Talks Podcast
  • People
    • Global Leadership Team and Partners
    • Partners
    • Managing Consultants
    • Board of Directors
    • Founders
  • About Us
    • Our History
    • Our Vision
    • Our Perspective
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Let's Talk

A Fatal Attraction: The Case Against Behavioral Safety Approaches

Published by Mike Goddu at October 27, 2014
JMJ Associates Logo
A Fatal Attraction: The Case Against Behaviour-based Safety Approaches
Latest News
  • Blog
  • Safety

A Fatal Attraction: The Case Against Behavioral Safety Approaches

Latest Blogs

October 27, 2014


Note: This is Part I in a series of posts entitled "Evolving Beyond Behaviorism." To read Part II, please click here

"Professor Sidney Dekker of Griffiths University, Todd Conklin of Los Alamos Laboratory and other current thought leaders in safety rail against behavioral safety approaches. Still, behavioral safety thinking remains at the foundation of safety in the construction industry worldwide."

At JMJ, our consulting to world-scale construction projects includes work with the largest companies in the energy and resources industries and a broad spectrum of their construction contractors. These companies are not only the best at their business, but also at doing their business safely.

Virtually all are using behavioral safety programs as the core of their “people-based” safety programs, and they swear by these programs. They back these programs up with resources, systems, sophisticated reports and metrics which in turn drive, measure and reward behaviour. On a given project site, managers can point to improvements in a sub-contractor performance once the BBS, ZAP, ZIP, PBS, or RBL programs take hold HES Directors also point to enterprise and industry-wide improvements in injury and incident rates.

But progress has stalled. Rates are not falling further. Fatal incidents plague virtually all operating companies, large construction contractors and countries. Despite sustained investment, teeth-gnashing and moralizing, no apparent path for success has emerged. As a result, managers on most sites are driving behavioral programs harder, more rigorously and with more metrics and systems to reinforce them.

“We’ve sent hundreds of workers home for ‘making the wrong choices’, and although it helped at first, it has not fundamentally improved our safety. We have got to do something different.” - Construction Director, worksite of 6000 workers

Behaviorism, in vogue throughout the global construction industry, was basically abandoned by forward-looking psychologists 50 years ago. James Reason, perhaps the most influential thinker in modern safety management, de-bunked behavior “as a cause of incidents” almost 20 years ago. Professor Sidney Dekker of Griffiths University, Todd Conklin of Los Alamos Laboratory and other current thought leaders in safety rail against behavior-based approaches. Still, behavior-based thinking remains at the foundation of safety in the construction industry worldwide.

Why?

Here are some common reasons:

  • It provides a logical explanation to incidents and near incidents.
  • It gives managers and safety organizations something clear and measurable to work on.
  • It gives the organization something to fix, by extension, something or someone to blame. Thus it helps manage liability and public perception.
  • It gives the organization ‘leading indicators.’
  • It’s a way to get the attention of and do some basic training for workers.

These are all very attractive attributes to safety, site and corporate managers. But this infatuation masks the underlying issues of their workplaces, and leads managers in the same direction that in fact causes the injuries! Perhaps this is a “fatal attraction.”

JMJ suggested that perhaps there was a bigger opportunity here. Rather than just reinforcing the rules, what might provide a better overall outcome?

I believe a more fundamental shift in worker engagement and safety management is needed.

My next blog will address why this attraction exists and point to new avenues for managing Safety Differently…

I welcome your comments.

On March 19, 11:30 AM at the Hilton Brisbane Hotel in Brisbane, Australia, Mike Goddu will be co-hosting a Business Lunch with Professor Sidney Dekker, discussing the limits of behaviorism and how to lead and manage Safety Differently.

RELATED: What Tennis Reveals About the Limits of Behaviour-based Safety

RELATED: Safety Leadership (Not Behavior-Based Safety) is the Pathway to Change Worker Behavior


View All Client Results

Capital Projects Client Results
DSME Completes TCO FGP WPMP Fabrication Safely and ahead of Schedule for the Tengizchevroil Expansion Project
DSME Completes
Client Results Manufacturing
Global Manufacturing Corporation Reduces Quality Defects and Improves Bottom-Line Performance
One of the worl
DSHI Fabrication Yards in Korea Builds Strong Safety Culture on TCO FGP Major Capital Project
Client Results Safety
DSHI Fabrication Yards in Korea Builds Strong Safety Culture on TCO FGP Major Capital Project
At Korean fabri
Japanese Engineering & Construction Corporat Achieves Breakthrough Improvement in Safety Performance
Client Results Safety
Japanese Engineering & Construction Corporation Achieves Breakthrough Improvement in Safety Performance
The JGC Corpora
Russian Petroleum Operations Company Achieves a Shift in its Health and Safety Culture
Client Results Safety
Russian Petroleum Operations Company Achieves a Shift in its Health and Safety Culture in 9 Months
SPD had been wo


Author

Mike Goddu

Latest Blogs

JMJ Leadership Skills
Blog Leadership Development
How Do You as a Leader Generate and Elevate Real Conversations Faster, in a Safe Space and More Creatively within an Organization?
Leaders need hi
Construction Safety Week
Blog
What has the Foundational Power to Change the Construction Industry?
It costs nothin
JMJ's Michael Huvane interviews Teichert's Dana Davis
Blog Safety
Teichert’s Safety Journey Enables Operational Excellence a Conversation with Dana Davis, President of Teichert Materials
Michael Huvane,
Professor Sidney Dekker of Griffiths University, Todd Conklin of Los Alamos Laboratory and other current thought leaders in safety rail against behavioral safety approaches. Still, behavioral safety thinking remains at the foundation of safety in the construction industry worldwide.

  • Author
Mike Goddu
Mike Goddu Author
Michael co-founded JMJ in 1987 and has more than 25 years of industry and consulting experience. In the early 90’s, Mike developed the firm’s High Performance Projects practice, and has led numerous commercial and government engagements for JMJ, including Bechtel Group’s work during the rebuilding of Kuwait following the 1990-91 war; petroleum and chemical projects for Chevron in the U.S. and Middle East; alignment and leadership development for multi-billion (USD) chemical plants in Venezuela, Saudi Arabia and Kuwait; and alliance development and project execution for a $3 billion (CD) Shell refinery project in Canada.
follow me
JMJ
  • Corporate Headquarters
    Arboretum Plaza One
    9442 N. Capital of Texas Highway, Suite 450,
    Austin, Texas 78759
  • +1 (512) 795-0795
  • Email Us

Services

  • Transformation Consultants
  • Safety Consultants
  • Leadership and Organizational Performance
  • Major Capital Projects
  • High Integrity Turnarounds™
  • The School of Coaching

Locations

  • Americas Office – Austin
  • APAC Office – Singapore
  • EMEA Office – London
  • Middle East Office – Doha
  • Kazakhstan Office – Atyrau
  • South Korea Office – Seoul
  • Australia Office – Perth

Connect

  • linkedin
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • Youtube
Privacy | Terms of Use | Trademarks | Accessibility | Cookie Policy | Feedback | Site Map |

© 2020 JMJ Associates LLP. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of JMJ Associates content or logo, including by framing or similar means, is prohibited without the prior written consent of JMJ Associates.

    Start Unlocking Human Performance


    Arrange a call with one of our consultants today. Please complete your details below:

    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
    This site uses cookies to provide you with a more personalised service. By using this site you agree to our use of cookies. Please read our cookie policy for more information on the cookies we use and how to delete or block them.Accept Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled

    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

    Non-necessary

    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

    SAVE & ACCEPT